04-11-2016, 12:18 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-11-2016, 12:25 PM by Mike Watterson.)
(03-11-2016, 11:26 PM)Mark Hennessy Wrote: Yes, I've certainly looked at load lines for bipolars and JFETs and MOSFETs. They're in almost every text book. But, I really don't know why. Sure, I understand what they mean, but I've *never* used them during the design process. And just to be clear, I do a lot with transistors - mostly bipolar - at low, medium and high power levels. Most of what I do is analogue. But I get by without reference to load lines. Perhaps I'm missing something?
They are not so much use on transformerless, totem pole or complementatry. How many single ended transistor class A power amps have you done? That's about the only thing they'd be much use for!
Earlier stages you might have an emitter resistor to set bias current and thus easily choose a collector load resistor so that Vce is roughly 1/2 HT - (emitter resistor x Ic).
So I've never used load lines on graphs for transistors either. Also most transistors have a much greater spread than valves so the graphs are only a guide line. You design with localised DC NFB and assume a minimum DC gain.
Even on Valves I've only used them for the SE class A output stage. Earlier stages I make an estimate of what Ia I want and the grid bias for that (which likely only has cathode resistors on Indirect heated Cathodes, most of my valve designs are Battery direct filament Rod Pentodes anyway), then calculate the Anode load (if any). RF/Osc/IF stages the Anode & Screen currents set the HT decoupling resistor values for the desired voltage.
I found that most transistor books covering RF, IF, Oscillators and basic Audio are based on earlier valve texts. This is especially obvious on oscillators where the explanations in the valve text books are better. Hence the transistor collector load lines.
Transistor RF power amps might use 12V to 48V and are usually push pull transformer coupled. Ones for FM only might be class C or B. For SSB they may be Class AB or A. For digital they are often class A. I have some 1W wide band RF push-pull ICs which are class A and need transformers or bifilar chokes for DC load. That sort of stuff can sometimes need load lines.
I've no idea how to use "load lines" on totem pole or complementary Class B or Class AB transformerless push pull.
Digital Switches, Class C, Class B, Class D doesn't need load lines.







